Editing Harper Lee
- Feb
- 04
- 2015
- Posted by Tammy Ditmore
- Posted in Editing, Events, Publishing
By now, anyone who pays any attention to the world of words knows that Harper Lee, author of To Kill a Mockingbird, is releasing a new book.
The stature of To Kill a Mockingbird, which was published in 1960, can surely be measured by the number of news outlets around the world that breathlessly announced the news on Tuesday. The promise of a new Harper Lee book trended on Twitter all day; at least half a dozen of my Facebook friends posted the news. Barnes and Noble emailed me to let me know I could preorder the book now to receive it shortly after its July release.
Along with the excitement, the announcement has aroused some suspicion and a bit of worry. Some people wonder whether Lee, who is 88 and reportedly not in good health, really understands what she has agreed to do. Others worry that Go Set a Watchman will not be very good, as if a less-than-stellar second book could tarnish To Kill a Mockingbird.
The Editor Who Inspired the Story
But I’m most fascinated by the editor angle (naturally). When announcing the release of her second book, Harper Lee provided a glimpse of the role played by an unidentified editor in the creation of her first book, the one that won a Pulitzer prize and still sells hundreds of thousands of copies annually.
In a statement issued by her publisher, Lee said, “In the mid-1950s, I completed a novel called Go Set a Watchman. It features the character known as Scout as an adult woman, and I thought it a pretty decent effort. My editor, who was taken by the flashbacks to Scout’s childhood, persuaded me to write a novel from the point of view of the young Scout.”
From now on, when people ask me what editors do, I will point them to that quote. According to Lee, To Kill a Mockingbird exists because an editor helped her create it after seeing what she had originally created. This editor saw the potential in Lee’s work but also saw what it could be if she reshaped it, refocused it, reimagined her story. Lee saw the potential in her editor’s advice and followed it.
The results speak for themselves. The young Scout is an unforgettable literary narrator; the power of To Kill a Mockingbird is multiplied because it is told from the perspective of an innocent young girl who becomes less innocent as the book unfolds. Apparently, it was Harper Lee’s editor who recognized that power and helped her tap into it.
I’ve looked through multiple news sources that include this statement but have not found a single one that explicitly identifies the editor who Lee said persuaded her to rewrite her book. That’s not too surprising because even when we get a glimpse of the “man behind the curtain,” the attention stays where it should be—on the author. It probably takes an editor to even recognize how Lee’s statement reveals the role her editor played in the success of To Kill a Mockingbird.
But that’s okay because the best editors know their best work should be invisible to most readers. They’re happy to do their work from the shadows, and they’re satisfied even when only a handful of people ever know the truth about how they saved the life of a book.
Just call us the Boo Radleys of the publishing world.
6 Responses so far.
Search
Blog Categories
Contact
Testimonials
Tammy’s approach to editing was like telling a story to someone who listens very well and offers suggestions only when something is confusing or grammatically incorrect (or embarrassing).
This book has been a major effort for me over the past 15 years—both emotionally and in time commitment. Your feedback helped me give it structure. Your insightful questions encouraged me to go deeper in my understanding and intentions, which provided enhanced clarity. Your recommendations provided a professional perspective that I needed towards getting it published. Thank you so much! When entertaining any future writing projects, you will be the first person I contact.
She worked with me chapter-by-chapter over the course of nearly a year to hone my writing through attention to style, organization, and mechanics. Her close reading and keen eye have been invaluable during my revision process. I learned important guidelines about preparing my manuscript for its final review through this pleasant experience of working with her.
Tammy Ditmore is an excellent editor. My writing improved grammatically, in structure, and clarity under her skilled eye.
Personally, I feel the editing process is the most important aspect of writing–it can be a nightmare if the editor and the writer are not on the same page. … Tammy knows what she is doing, she is easy to work with, and she delivers on time.
I appreciate Tammy’s willingness to ask questions when appropriate, flex on deadlines, offer sound advice, and rewrite sentences or sections as needed. Her command of substantive and copy editing make Tammy an asset to any project.
Tammy is sensitive to my work and does a great job to maintain the integrity of my writing and my voice!
Tammy Ditmore’s timely, thorough, detailed and accurate proofreading made my book print ready. She delivers high quality work on schedule and is a pleasure to work with.
I had a book manuscript that had a thorough edit by a copy editor, but there were many changes made and I wanted another set of eyes to look at it carefully. So I hired Tammy Ditmore to do a “final” proofread and flag anything that she found awkward, confusing or ill-fitting. That is a difficult job—to look both for errors and to comment, but that is what I needed. Tammy took it on and did a great job. Tammy also understands a schedule and finished the work on time—even ahead of time. Thank … Read more
Tammy Ditmore was the consummate professional. She was very humble in dealing with me and tailored her editing style to fit my specific needs. She was prompt and punctual with deadlines and was very open to communicating with me. I would hire her again in a heartbeat.”
Brilliant!
Thanks, Marla!
The hand that rocks the cradle…
Andy, I had never thought about editing being like mothering, but I guess it is really is!
Ah, we writers should all be so lucky as to have an editor with such perspective and for sight.
Thanks for sharing it ceedaddebbeecafd